CFTC Chair Michael Selig said on CNBC on Oct. 30 that the agency wants to offer exchanges, offshore ones like Binance included, the option of registering with the CFTC voluntarily, according to Bitcoin.com. Registered exchanges would come under a framework covering cybersecurity, market manipulation, customer protection and custody of assets. But the federal government cannot force every exchange to register without added authority from Congress. The idea builds on rule proposals issued on Oct. 5 (Regulation CTX and CAM), and the comment period runs until Dec. 14.
Sen. Cynthia Lummis argued that if the stalled Clarity Act had passed, firms acting at the request of law enforcement would have had legal protection when freezing suspicious transactions. Amanda Fischer, a former chief of staff at the SEC, pushed back that the bill requires stablecoin issuers to freeze on the basis of a court order. Patrick Wilson of the Solana Policy Institute replied that the bill includes a provision that shields issuers from civil lawsuits when they freeze voluntarily and temporarily. The bill stalled in the Senate on Sept. 15, short of the 60 votes needed to move forward.
BTC Macro Lab's view
The point for Japanese readers is that this incident supports Japan's response in the GMO case. When GMO Group was hit by a cyberattack, Japan's communications ministry asked carriers to block access to the attackers' site. It was a forceful step, contested because of its relationship with the secrecy of communications, and opinion was divided. In the Binance case, the freeze of about $3 billion came from issuers such as Tether and Circle. But the Clarity Act, which would give freezing firms legal protection, has not passed. Had it passed, the US government could have acted sooner and more effectively.
Both the CFTC's voluntary registration plan and the Clarity Act are systems meant to reduce the damage from incidents like this. The way Japan intervened first is a useful reference for the US debate.
Background
- Under the previous (Biden) administration, the SEC often took an enforcement-first approach, including lawsuits against exchanges. Now the CFTC is opening a path to registration and working on rules.
- The industry group Digital Chamber (more than 250 members) wrote to Congress asking for a bill narrowed to three points: segregation of customer assets, CFTC registration and examination authority, and multi-person approval for moving customer assets.
- In its letter, the group says stablecoin issuers and blockchain firms froze close to $3 billion (about ¥465 billion) within hours. Yen figures use $1 = ¥155.
Read the full Japanese article ▶
This article is provided for information only and does not recommend buying or selling any crypto asset or financial product. Please check primary sources and official announcements and make your own decisions at your own responsibility. We use AI in part of our work.